JUSTIN HOWELL

Product, design & technology

Brand · 4 min read

Authenticity is built into the experience

A brand earns trust when its promises survive contact with the product, the policies, and the people behind it.

Authenticity gets circled in brand workshops, underlined in strategy decks, and offered as the answer to almost any marketing problem. Used that way, the word tells us very little. What should a team actually do differently on Monday?

Start with the distance between what a company says and what someone experiences. A friendly campaign can lead to a confusing checkout. A promise of personal service can end in a support loop. Those are brand decisions, even when the brand team never sees them.

My wife and I run a Disney travel agency, and the clearest lessons on this arrive in our own inbox. A family planning a trip judges us on whether a payment deadline is clear and whether a question gets a real answer. No campaign fixes a confusing email. The fix lives in the service.

Give people something they can check

People can compare a company’s advertising with reviews, employee accounts, and their own experience. That helps. But more information doesn’t automatically make the truth easier to find.

A practical response is to make your own claims specific. If a product is easier to use, show the task it simplifies. If a service saves time, explain what you measured. If you promise to stand behind a purchase, make the return policy easy to find and easy to understand.

Give the reader enough detail to judge the claim. An honest limitation can do more than another confident adjective.

AI makes the boundary worth spelling out

AI adds another question to brand communication: what is being presented as real? There’s a meaningful difference between using a tool to explore a layout and presenting an invented customer as someone who used your product. The team needs a clear boundary before either reaches an audience.

Dove offers a specific example. In its 2024 Keep Beauty Real campaign, it committed to never using AI to create or distort women’s images. The pledge connects a production decision to the brand’s longstanding position on beauty. Dove’s Keep Beauty Real commitment.

My takeaway is to define what your audience is being asked to believe, then protect it. A customer story should describe a real experience. A product demonstration should represent what the product can do. Someone needs to own that standard, regardless of how the material was made.

A value is only as real as the decision it changes

Patagonia shows what this looks like at the scale of ownership. In September 2022, the Chouinard family transferred the company’s voting stock to the Patagonia Purpose Trust and its nonvoting stock to the Holdfast Collective. Patagonia remains a for-profit company; profits left after reinvestment are distributed to support environmental work. Patagonia’s explanation of its ownership.

That isn’t proof that every decision the company makes is beyond criticism, or that another business needs the same structure. It shows a stated value given practical force.

Most versions of this work are smaller. A company that promises accessibility can budget for testing with disabled users. A company that promises clarity can rewrite its pricing page and remove surprise charges. The useful question is which decision your stated value changes.

Stay close to the experience

Understanding people takes more than naming an audience in a presentation. Read the support requests. Watch someone attempt the task. Ask where they expected one thing and got another. Make room for answers that complicate the story you wanted to tell.

I led brand strategy at Interfolio through its integration into Elsevier, and the lesson held at that scale too. The brand team could describe a promise. The product and policy decisions that kept it usually sat with other teams.

Then connect what you learn to someone who can act on it. If customers keep misunderstanding a fee, the product, marketing, and support teams need to work the same problem. A warmer email template will only get them so far.

This is where empathy becomes useful: a clearer explanation, a corrected charge, a flow that no longer leaves someone stranded. People should be able to feel the difference in the service.

Make consistency part of the work

Before shipping a campaign or a feature, ask what it promises, where that promise gets tested, and who can fix the gap. Keep asking after launch. When something falls short, explain what happened and what will change.

That’s the version of authenticity I find useful. It gives designers, marketers, and product teams a shared responsibility: make a promise the business can keep, then keep improving the experience behind it.